Our Boston Massacre Moment

The parallels are striking and undeniable. An unpopular, external military force shoots and kills protesters haranguing the officers, demanding they leave. Snowballs are thrown.

British soldiers panicked and fired on the crowd in Boston, killing five and wounding six more.

More than 255 years later, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer shot three times and killed Renee Good, mother of three, as she attempted to leave the scene.

What became known as the Boston Massacre in 1770 inflamed the colonists and dramatically escalated resistance to British tyranny. It rallied the population for independence and became an important precursor to the American Revolutionary War.

The British soldiers were arrested for murder the next morning and, controversially, were represented by John Adams at trial, who believed above all else in justice, due process, and the rule of law. (Adams later became America’s second president.)

What will happen now after the murder of Renee Good? Despite the obvious similarities with the Boston Massacre, there are differences too.

There is no John Adams for the officer, just a collection of inexperienced sycophants now populating the Justice Department. Perhaps that’s one more reason why Jonathan Ross, the officer who fired through the windshield and side windows of Good’s car was immediately whisked away and protected by ICE, which has blocked access to evidence and refused to allow Minnesota officials to be part of any investigation.

Unlike the Boston Massacre, the details of which remain murky (were the soldiers ordered to fire on the crowd?), there is video of the killing in Minneapolis for all the world to see. It is shocking and unambiguous.

We cannot sit by idly any longer. We must demand an open trial of this ICE officer. We must peacefully stand and be heard, here and across the nation, that this militarized, deliberately provocative invasion of our cities cannot continue. Let this be our Boston Massacre moment.

Similar Posts

  • ICE Supporters Try and Suppress Bearing Witness Demonstrations

    The weekly Bearing Witness protests at ICE headquarters on District Avenue have become a regional center of peaceful resistance, drawing 700–900 participants each week. Organized by a broad interfaith coalition, the demonstrations elevate the voices of those harmed by ICE while reaffirming a commitment to nonviolence. That very commitment has triggered escalating efforts to suppress the protests: parking bans, intimidation, and towing by powerful real estate interests and complicit local authorities. As businesses and police “bend the knee” to protect ICE, Bearing Witness remains resolute. Peaceful assembly is not a threat—it is a constitutional right, and it will continue to grow. See our Letter to National Development

  • Protecting Massachusetts Communities Campaign Launched at State House Rally

    A coalition of immigrant rights organizations, legislators, union leaders, and concerned citizens gathered outside Boston’s Statehouse on Oct. 22 to launch Protecting Massachusetts Communities (PMC) — a campaign to legally defend against the freedom of ICE agents to target, hunt down, arrest and deport the thousands of immigrants and refugees living and working in our communities.

    “Operation Patriot,” the federal government’s escalation of immigrant deportations from Massachusetts last spring netted 1,500 arrests in May alone, mostly in the Boston “sanctuary city” area.”Operation Patriot 2.0”, which began in September, has yielded another 1,500 arrests is ongoing.

    ICE’s growing use of violence in abducting immigrants spreads a constant fear in their homes and work places, not only in metropolitan Boston and its suburbs but also in Worcester, Lowell, Fall River, Framingham and Nantucket. Currently, the operations are reported to be moving into the Merrimack Valley region. Immigrants are afraid to take public transportation, go to work or send their children to school for fear of being trapped in a massive ICE dragnet based on racial profiling, now encouraged by the Supreme Court.

    Contrary to federal claims of targeting only hardcore criminals, up to 80% of those indiscriminately scooped up, detained, stripped of their rights and deported are found to have no criminal record.

  • Proposed OMB Rule would give Political Commissars Veto Power on All Federal Science Grants

    A new federal rule, OMB 0034-2026, hands the White House direct political control over every federal research grant. Buried in dull bureaucratic language, it lets the Office of Management and Budget—now run by Project 2025 architect Russell Vought—override the individual agencies that have always tailored their own grant processes. Its core move, Section 200.205, installs presidential appointees inside every agency with sole authority to approve or deny grants. Peer review by working scientists still happens, but its verdicts become merely advisory—and appointees are actually pressured to reject the proposals experts rate highest. Grants must align with administration priorities, can be killed at any time on a whim, and are barred from researchers tied to advocacy groups, foreign collaborators, or public communication. The OMB actuaries no longer just audit; they command. It is a unitary seizure of power over American science, the very basis of our prosperity and standard of living, and the time to fight it is now through public comments

  • Profiles in Courage

    At Lexington Alarm we have a theory of resistance. When people have courage to take small actions they generate a response. No action is too small or insignificant not to count. Sometimes the responses strengthen the resistance in surprising ways. This creates a snowball effect, and the resistance to abuses and attacks on our constitutional rights grows stronger.

    We have two really important examples from the past two weeks.

  • Building the Resistance, One Circle of Trust at a Time

    Toby Sackton at First Parish Wayland: Why Movements Are Built on Trust, Not Leaders.

    In a talk at First Parish in Wayland in March, Toby Sackton gave what might be the most complete account yet of why this moment demands something different from conventional politics and what Lexington Alarm has been building since Patriots Day 2025.

    The talk, titled “Building Effective Resistance,” was part history, part organizing theory, part urgent call to action. Sackton began with the personal. “I have been an activist since the 1960s,” he told the room. “When the war in Ukraine started, I was glued to the news every day. Gaza was worse. When Trump was reelected, it was another shock. Truly, the world was coming apart. I doom scrolled. I read every atrocity from doge, the attack on science every firing, every attack on immigrants and Black people.”

    What broke the spiral, he said, was not a policy win or an electoral outcome it was human connection. “When a group of us founded Lexington Alarm one year ago, for the first time since the Vietnam era, I felt part of this broad network of people, a movement, that had majority support, all working towards a rough common vision grounded in the ideas of equality and the promise of what America could be.”

    Sackton started with a diagnosis. “Since the beginning of 2025, the laws and traditions that have shaped the last hundred years of our history have been violently attacked.